Welcome to RVForums.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest RV Community on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, review campgrounds
  • Get the most out of the RV Lifestyle
  • Invite everyone to RVForums.com and let's have fun
  • Commercial/Vendors welcome

Tow vehicle shopping woes

Welcome to RVForums.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends and let's have fun
  • Commercial/Vendors welcome
  • Friendliest RV community on the web

Bigblockyeti

RVF VIP
Joined
Feb 28, 2023
Messages
477
Location
Upstate SC
RV Make
Still shopping
I'm casually shopping around for a larger truck, a 1/2 ton will do all I want and then some, a 3/4 ton would be far beyond what I would want or need or be willing to spend on a depreciating asset. I've looked at GM and they stopped caring about building a 1/2 ton truck for doing truck stuff when they offered a decently powerful 6.2L engine, but only in high spec trim levels and burning premium fuel, both are non-starters for me. Dodge seems to me like they're always on the verge of producing a reliable transmission, just can't evolve past the verge into reality. Ford seems like they still offer a 1/2 ton truck for actually being used as a truck and not something crossed shopped with a $110K Sucker Urbanite Vehicle. I was able to spec out a 2023 2wd F-150 with the 3.5LTT engine, crewcab, 6.5' bed and spartan interior with rubber floors & black urethane steering wheel for $46,930 which certainly would have to be ordered. Probably wouldn't have to pay above MSRP but highly unlikely it would be under and I'd have to wait a while for it to be built too. Here's the rub, it actually doesn't have any towing package despite being able to tow 11,300lbs as equipped, the "max towing package" is really just an invitation to spend another $4K. The only functionalily in that package is an integrated brake controller, class IV towing hitch, larger rear springs and 3.73 (vs. the 3.55 locking I spec'd) locking rear axle & 9.75" ring gear (presumably an overall larger axle assembly). It also includes a littany of dodads that might make trailering easier for someone who has no business pulling a trailer in the first place, it doesn't even include trailer towing mirrors. The class IV hitch and brake controller I can source for under $350 in the aftermarket, the same for towing mirrors at ~$150 vs. whatever ford charges for them. The bigger axle, 3.73 ratio and heavier springs having a net price of over $3650 seems like a bad case of diminishing returns or greedy execs. or marketing incompetence, I'm guessing a blend. I know I'm ranting but I remember when you could pick what you wanted a la carte from any of the big three, including a proper manual transmission.

This is making a 2023 E350 cut away chassis with the Godzilla motor for $38K and change start to seem like a bargain!
 
I'm casually shopping around for a larger truck, a 1/2 ton will do all I want and then some, a 3/4 ton would be far beyond what I would want or need or be willing to spend on a depreciating asset. I've looked at GM and they stopped caring about building a 1/2 ton truck for doing truck stuff when they offered a decently powerful 6.2L engine, but only in high spec trim levels and burning premium fuel, both are non-starters for me. Dodge seems to me like they're always on the verge of producing a reliable transmission, just can't evolve past the verge into reality. Ford seems like they still offer a 1/2 ton truck for actually being used as a truck and not something crossed shopped with a $110K Sucker Urbanite Vehicle. I was able to spec out a 2023 2wd F-150 with the 3.5LTT engine, crewcab, 6.5' bed and spartan interior with rubber floors & black urethane steering wheel for $46,930 which certainly would have to be ordered. Probably wouldn't have to pay above MSRP but highly unlikely it would be under and I'd have to wait a while for it to be built too. Here's the rub, it actually doesn't have any towing package despite being able to tow 11,300lbs as equipped, the "max towing package" is really just an invitation to spend another $4K. The only functionalily in that package is an integrated brake controller, class IV towing hitch, larger rear springs and 3.73 (vs. the 3.55 locking I spec'd) locking rear axle & 9.75" ring gear (presumably an overall larger axle assembly). It also includes a littany of dodads that might make trailering easier for someone who has no business pulling a trailer in the first place, it doesn't even include trailer towing mirrors. The class IV hitch and brake controller I can source for under $350 in the aftermarket, the same for towing mirrors at ~$150 vs. whatever ford charges for them. The bigger axle, 3.73 ratio and heavier springs having a net price of over $3650 seems like a bad case of diminishing returns or greedy execs. or marketing incompetence, I'm guessing a blend. I know I'm ranting but I remember when you could pick what you wanted a la carte from any of the big three, including a proper manual transmission.

This is making a 2023 E350 cut away chassis with the Godzilla motor for $38K and change start to seem like a bargain!
My 2021 Silverado 1500 with the 6.2l engine drinks regular very happily.

From the Owner's Manual:
Recommended Fuel (6.2L V8 Engine)
Premium unleaded gasoline meeting ASTM specification D4814 with a posted octane
rating of 93 — (R+M)/2 — is highly recommended for best performance and fuel
economy. Unleaded gasoline with an octane rated as low as 87 can be used.
According to all of the online research I have done, the "best performance and fuel economy" is marginal, if it is real at all. If you don't get pinging, you're fine.
 
Seems you have made up your mind, I think? Like knobs post above, my 5.7 is happy with 87 octane. Over 100k and counting without anything issues. Heavy metal is better for towing. Yes even if the trailer is a utility trailer. 6 cylinder engines, no matter how equipped are generally more suited as daily drivers.

I grew up a standard trans guy, but when you need to throw the clutch further than normal to start the engine, back problems start. That combined with steeper shift points, make a quality 8+speed automatic transmission a no brainer. Oh I guess I didn't state my ZF transmission has roughly 500 rpm shift points. It is a low friction transmission and has a very good reputation, also with 100k miles with no signs of weakness, with mostly towing miles.

Like I said, it sounds like you have you heart set, and I won't interfere with what your heart is telling you.

My .002 worth.
 
I'm happy with my Tundra. New gen has more power and higher payload and towing but I know it's a controversial vehicle and not just in the looks department.
 
I'm happy with my Tundra. New gen has more power and higher payload and towing but I know it's a controversial vehicle and not just in the looks department.
Last fall I was reading a comparision between similarly equipped '22 Tundra and '21 F-150 and the F-150 beat the Toyota in every category by 3-10% from towing, mileage, fuel economy, handling, braking, towing, acceleration & fuel capacity all for about $4K less ($2K less for the same '22 MY). I missed out on ordering exactly what I wanted in a 2020 Tundra for $38K with six passenger seating, max towing and an 8' bed with 4x4, that was also with the 400K mile 5.7L V-8 vs. the new tiny turbo motor. That same setup is no longer available and the next closest thing is $63K. I know [mod edit politics] to lower our expectations but the low part of "lower" seems to have no bottom!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Agree with most everything you say, but wouldn't have any of the Ecoburst engines, certainly not for towing anything.
 
I don't really want one, but the torque they produce at a relatively low speed can't be touched by anything shy of a big block. I will say that for $38K and change that cutaway E350 with a normal 6 speed auto vs. the zillion speed (and failure point) slush boxes, dually or not and 7.3L motor is starting to look appealing for a custom build especially with a 11,500GVWR and 18,500GCWR. Heck, that's still $10K less than my brother just spent on a mid-level trim Honda Odyssey
 
The problem I see is carmax is calling a used 1/2 ton truck priced at $53K+ a "great deal" which is anything but to me. The best I've seen so far was a clean 2014 RAM 2500 4×4 diesel with 6 seatbelts and 70K miles for $40K. The seller was going to sell it with the camper and allegedly for a "good deal" but the camper needed a little work before he was ready to sell it and the truck sold pretty quickly alone. I priced out a new F150 with a bunch more power than that diesel 1/2 ton GMC for under $47K new.
 

Latest posts

Latest resources

Back
Top