FYI Top Tier Fuel

[redbaron]

if you look at the brands that offer top tier, you would be challenged to find fuel that isn’t TopTier.

Mainly Walmart, Costco, and other ultra cheap fuel is the problem fuel.

QT, Exxon, Mobil, Shell, Marathon, Chevron, Valero are among the many retailers that are TopTier

 

[Rollin Ollen]

if you look at the brands that offer top tier, you would be challenged to find fuel that isn’t TopTier.

Mainly Walmart, Costco, and other ultra cheap fuel is the problem fuel.

QT, Exxon, Mobil, Shell, Marathon, Chevron, Valero are among the many retailers that are TopTier

It appears the Costco gasoline IS top tier. https://www.costco.ca/gasoline-q-and-a.html

 

[Joe Dutchstar]

Reviewing Top Tier fuel philosophy of high detergent formulation and how that might solve the intake coking from DI engines, many brands now use both a multi-port system and a Direct injection system in combination. This solves much of the intake valve and track carbon issue.

Interesting solution.

From the internet

Auto Brands with Dual Fuel Injection

Several auto brands have implemented dual fuel injection systems, combining direct injection (DI) and port fuel injection (PFI). Toyota and Ford are notable examples that use this technology in their engines.

Toyota's dual injection system, known as D-4S, integrates both direct and port fuel injection to optimize performance, emissions, and fuel economy. This system has been used in various Toyota and Lexus models since around 2007, including the Lexus GS SUV, Toyota/Scion FR-S F86, and the Toyota Highlander and Tacoma

Ford also utilizes dual fuel injection systems in some of its newer engines. For instance, the 3.5L and 2.7L EcoBoost engines in Ford vehicles from 2017 onwards, as well as the Mustang 5.0L and F-150 5.0L engines from 2018 onwards, incorporate this technology

These systems aim to leverage the advantages of both direct and port fuel injection, such as better vaporization and cooling effects, while mitigating their respective disadvantages, like carbon buildup and soot production

 

[dave54]

The video pimps Shell fuel. It may be better (or not, I really do not know). However -- Shell in my area runs 30+ cents higher per gallon. The higher fuel expense now must be weighed against the savings from reduced engine wear that will only show up long after I replace the vehicle.

 

[redbaron]

It appears the Costco gasoline IS top tier. https://www.costco.ca/gasoline-q-and-a.html

You are correct -- this is good news. The pages vary between US & CANADA

From the CANADA site linked in your post:

vs the US page (https://www.costco.com/gasoline-q-and-a.html)

 

[Crazydog]

I’m not the engineer. All I know is that my Kia, BMW, and Chevrolet all have labels, clear print in the manual, and numerous TSB stating that TopTier fuel is required for optimal performance.

If not using TopTier, then you must use an additive that meets or exceeds.

The manual also states that you should not mix additives with TopTier gas. Any of the vehicles manufactured since 2004 from GM, BMW, Toyota, and Honda require this.

I suspect the timing is based on the corn fuel being introduced and further damaging engines without the proper burn.

This is from the top tier alliance

I guarantee you would never feel or notice any difference if using "top tier" fuel or el cheapo brand.

 

[redbaron]

I guarantee you would never feel or notice any difference if using "top tier" fuel or el cheapo brand.

Well since I keep most of my vehicles until they die, I’ll just continue to maintain them and use the recommended fuels.

I have 4 vehicles with over 200k miles and 1 of them 389k. Seems to be working for me.

 

[GypsyR]

Many many years ago I borrowed my Mom's Datsun 310 (Yes, THAT long ago). She told me to be sure to refill it with "good" gas before I returned it. Hopefully from the local Exxon station. Being in the habit of running my vehicle on the cheapest gas possible I ignored this request. Yep, she was right. She called me and made me drive the crummy gas out of her car. It would sputter sometimes and actually die at stoplights. It did NOT like cheap gas. I still run the cheap stuff in my cars though.

That said, "octane" is another matter. Octane does not equate to quality. High octane means it the fuel is more resistant to burning. You do not want to use it in a lower compression engine that doesn't need it. If you do then you are giving up a bit of performance AND mileage. Not a lot but it's there. The old rule of thumb is to run the lowest octane fuel you can without your engine pinging. This is complicated by newer engine setups. In them if their fuel octane rating is too low they will simply retard the engine timing when ping or detonation is sensed with you none the wiser. Mostly. Run 87 octane in something like a supercharged Nissan Pathfinder that comes from the factory needing 93 octane and you WILL notice the lack of performance.
About the only way to prove you NEED higher octane is to monitor the OBD system while driving on that fuel. With a capable bi-directional scanner then you can see how on grades (most likely) the knock sensor is picking up detonation and the PCM is retarding the timing for you to prevent engine damage.
All vehicle manufacturers publish what octane fuel their vehicles require, in the owner's manual if nowhere else. Generally it is correct to follow that. At higher altitudes you can lower octane. In most of the country the lowest octane is 87. At "high" altitudes you will see 85 available. When you see 85 for sale is when you know you are high enough to make a change.

Some people run a higher octane to be "safe". Uusally because they have no idea what premium fuel actually is. To me that's just flushing money down the toilet.

As for additives, last I checked Chevron's Techron was the only one "approved" by Bosch. Been a while since I looked though. By the way, Bosch basically invented modern fuel injection so they kind of have a clue. Chevron fuels advertise that they already have Techron in them. However they don't qualify that. It might be one drop of additive per million gallons or something, we don't know. I have actually seen Techron help with some minor running issues related to "dirty" fuel injectors. I kind of like proof like that. I don't really use it much but you can bet there's a bottle of it in my garage. (Doesn't do diddly for carbureted engines though, unfortunately.)

 

[redbaron]

Chevron's Techron is Top-Tier approved fuel and meets the guidelines.

Bosch, being part of the German group that pushed for TopTier, was a major contributor for TopTier specifications, and approves TopTier in Port fuel injection as well as Gas-Direct Injection.

 

[Rosy]

Many many years ago I borrowed my Mom's Datsun 310 (Yes, THAT long ago). She told me to be sure to refill it with "good" gas before I returned it. Hopefully from the local Exxon station. Being in the habit of running my vehicle on the cheapest gas possible I ignored this request. Yep, she was right. She called me and made me drive the crummy gas out of her car. It would sputter sometimes and actually die at stoplights. It did NOT like cheap gas. I still run the cheap stuff in my cars though.

That said, "octane" is another matter. Octane does not equate to quality. High octane means it the fuel is more resistant to burning. You do not want to use it in a lower compression engine that doesn't need it. If you do then you are giving up a bit of performance AND mileage. Not a lot but it's there. The old rule of thumb is to run the lowest octane fuel you can without your engine pinging. This is complicated by newer engine setups. In them if their fuel octane rating is too low they will simply retard the engine timing when ping or detonation is sensed with you none the wiser. Mostly. Run 87 octane in something like a supercharged Nissan Pathfinder that comes from the factory needing 93 octane and you WILL notice the lack of performance.
About the only way to prove you NEED higher octane is to monitor the OBD system while driving on that fuel. With a capable bi-directional scanner then you can see how on grades (most likely) the knock sensor is picking up detonation and the PCM is retarding the timing for you to prevent engine damage.
All vehicle manufacturers publish what octane fuel their vehicles require, in the owner's manual if nowhere else. Generally it is correct to follow that. At higher altitudes you can lower octane. In most of the country the lowest octane is 87. At "high" altitudes you will see 85 available. When you see 85 for sale is when you know you are high enough to make a change.

Some people run a higher octane to be "safe". Uusally because they have no idea what premium fuel actually is. To me that's just flushing money down the toilet.

As for additives, last I checked Chevron's Techron was the only one "approved" by Bosch. Been a while since I looked though. By the way, Bosch basically invented modern fuel injection so they kind of have a clue. Chevron fuels advertise that they already have Techron in them. However they don't qualify that. It might be one drop of additive per million gallons or something, we don't know. I have actually seen Techron help with some minor running issues related to "dirty" fuel injectors. I kind of like proof like that. I don't really use it much but you can bet there's a bottle of it in my garage. (Doesn't do diddly for carbureted engines though, unfortunately.)

Excellent post.

We do have Chevron stations around here but they're few and far between.

 

[Crazydog]

Well since I keep most of my vehicles until they die, I’ll just continue to maintain them and use the recommended fuels.

I have 4 vehicles with over 200k miles and 1 of them 389k. Seems to be working for me.

I currently have a 1997 Ram 1500 that has over 304K miles and have always used whatever gas is cheapest regardless of retailer. Just goes to show you it doesn't matter.
I've also always used the orange Fram filters that people always say you shouldn't use.

 

[redbaron]

I currently have a 1997 Ram 1500 that has over 304K miles and have always used whatever gas is cheapest regardless of retailer. Just goes to show you it doesn't matter.
I've also always used the orange Fram filters that people always say you shouldn't use.

I don’t understand your point.

In 1997, engineering wasn’t designed for top tier fuel. It also wasn’t designed for corn fuel. My 1998 ram 2500 with 380k runs very well, but isn’t near the power or economy of my 2011 Chevy 2500 gas with 230k miles on it.

The 2011 gets only top tier, as the engineering was designed for it.

The 1998 gets whatever the ranch hands put in it as the engineering isn’t gas specifically mentioned.

So if you follow the topic and what I have been saying, you will see consistency between following manufacturer engineering specs.

And as said earlier, if you don’t have a vehicle designed for top tier fuel, then there is no need for it.

 

[GypsyR]

I've also always used the orange Fram filters that people always say you shouldn't use.

You can use them, they are just not good for certain engines and other filters are certainly better choices. Decades ago I used nothing but Fram. Noticed my old daily driver Mustang with a 289 would rattle upon startup on cold mornings. Then one day they didn't have a Fram for my car on the shelf but Ford/Motorcraft ones were about the same price. I was amazed the next day to find my early morning startup engine rattle to have disappeared. Same oil and all just a different filter.
Later at the Volvo dealership I was a tech at came a service bulletin advising against using such oil filters for the exact same reasons I quit using them. Owners were complaining about startup rattle. Thye had no check valve in them them to keep oil from leaking down overnight. Forward a couple of decades we have the internet and people discussing the same old Fram issues. What's amazing is that Fram never bothered to correct their design issue in all those years. They obviously just do not care at all. Wix, Purolator, Bosch, and others don't seem to have that problem putting a little check valve in their filters. I happily use those brands too.

This check valve issue plain does not apply to some engines though. Like my wife's Toyota. It may not be a problem to certain Dodges either, I haven't looked into it.